Accounting: What's the Real World of Accounting Like?
by Addison Carey III
For
recent accounting graduates, life holds the mysterious, age-old question: what
is it like in the real world? In particular, what is it like to work daily as an
accountant and what does it take to succeed in your accounting career? The
answers to those questions come in part from knowing yourself and your own
goals, then realizing that there are several types of accounting careers. Your
success will depend partly on whether the accounting path you choose fits your
goals and your lifestyle. Whether you advance depends upon the structure of the
company you work for. If you choose to work as one of three accountants, you may
have to wait until one of the two above you leave or retire before you can move
up. Consider the areas of accounting.
Areas of Accounting
Early in your career, preferably while still in
college, you will want to get an idea of what kind of accounting field you wish
to enter. You may already know that there are three types of businesses, and
accounting fits into each one:
Sole proprietor – a single,
independent CPA practitioner with several reliable clients
Partnership – start a CPA firm
with other CPAs and share clients, or join a firm already established. This
provides advantages such as taking time off or reducing the workload or
liability.
Corporation – joining a large
company with several accountants. In this case, you have little liability but
also not as much control.
In addition to these, you will want to decide
whether to work in a for-profit firm in private industry or a not-for-profit
organization such as a city, state or federal government agency. Private
industry jobs normally pay more than government jobs, but there is also less job
security. While all jobs have an "office politics" element, some jobs are
clearly more political than others (e.g, handgun or tobacco manufacturers, or
abortion clinics). Also, be aware that government jobs' salaries are generally
publicized – and that means politicized. So, if any person or position makes too
much money, the civil service commission may feel pressure from politicians,
public interest groups or rival government agencies to modify the pay scale to
reflect the public's priorities (e.g., police or public school teachers vs.
accountants).
Finally, you will want to decide what branch of
accounting you prefer to specialize in. Here are some examples:
General accounting – posting
journal entries, posting and monitoring accounts receivable or accounts payable,
reconciliations of accounts, keeping track of amortization schedules, monitoring
investment income, etc.
Financial analysis – comparing
actual income and expenses to budget or prior year, and reporting on the causes
of variances. This also includes balance sheet analysis, where you ensure that a
balance sheet account is reported at the proper level. These include extensive
primary and secondary research.
Taxation – preparing and
submitting tax forms for individuals or corporations. This may also include
answering clients' questions or providing information to authorized parties.
Audit – testing client
transactions and accounting policies and procedures to ensure management reports
fairly represent the financial condition of the business, based on some standard
such as Generally Accepted Accounting Procedures (GAAP). This includes internal
audit (done with company employees) or external audit (done with independent
CPAs).
Consulting – providing clients and
business with ideas to improve their financial condition or profitability.
Major Accounting Firms
Many aspiring accountants start their careers
with a major accounting firm. While those firms in fact do accounting, most of
their business comes from consulting, auditing, and other attest engagements. In
many cases, starting at an accounting firm allows you to become exposed to many
facets of accounting and many types of businesses.
Most of the Fortune 500 companies and many
public companies are audited by the "Big Four" accounting firms, that is, the
ones ranking in the top four in the country in revenues and professional staff.
They are:
- Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu
- Ernst & Young
- KPMG
- PricewaterhouseCoopers
However, over the past few years, the Big Four
have been losing clients and other major national firms, such as the following,
have been gaining them. Other major national firms:
- BDO Seidman
- Grant Thornton
- McGladrey & Pullen
While these companies are large and provide good
compensation and some opportunity for advancement, they also pressure their
employees to pass the CPA Exam. Also, only a few will make it to the level of
"partner" or "managing partner," where the large salaries are made. More likely
than not, you will stay at an accounting firm for two to three years, then move
on to industry, as the compensation and opportunities for advancement are
greater in a regular company. A firm that you may audit may seek your services
as an employee.
Salaries: The salary for
entry-level accountants ranges from 40 to 60 thousand.
Before you get into the Real World of
Accounting
If you are a junior or senior accounting
student, you are almost certainly contemplating your work options after
graduation. Before interviewing with prospective employers, ask yourself the
following questions:
(1) Do I want to work with a small,
local firm or a large national firm? And more specifically, do I want a
clear, fast path to advancement, or am I willing to wait awhile, until a
path opens up?
(2) Do I prefer a regular,
nine-to-five workday, or am I willing to work additional overtime and
weekends on a normal basis?
(3) Do I prefer to do more mundane
yet essential tasks, or do I want diverse and complicated assignments?
(4) Do I prefer an "easygoing" office
environment or would I be able to handle an "intense" one?
(5) Do I prefer to work at the same
office location all the time or am I willing to travel regularly?
Be honest with yourself when answering these
questions. For instance, it's easy to say, "I'll do anything for the right
amount of money," but it's very different to be paid well but to be unhappy with
your job. Often you can't know how much you will enjoy your job until you are
well into it. But you can certainly ask your interviewer specific questions
about the firm they are representing and the position for which you are
applying. Also, researching the company, visiting the job site and talking to
current employees can provide valuable insights into what to expect if you were
to choose that particular place to spend most of your waking hours.
So, what can you expect when you walk through
the doors for your first day of work? For one thing, before you go directly to
work, you will need information – and it doesn't just come from a book! You
will have to access the computer, acquire source documents, run reports, and do
research in books, periodicals, journals, and other secondary sources. Beyond
that, you will need to interview the people you work with: managers, co-workers,
clients, and others with valuable information.
During my 15-year accounting career, I have
worked for several different companies, all different and all presenting
challenges and opportunities. Here are a few that I believe illustrate what you
can expect on similar types of jobs.
Case 1: Civil Service:
The Tourist Mecca
I recommend that every new accountant take the
civil service examinations for local, state, and federal positions. What is it
like working for an organization that comes under civil service?
Early in my career, I acquired an accounting job
at a local real estate management company in a major tourist destination. This
was a small company, with about 60 employees, including 15 office staff. That
company was a city agency that comes under civil service. To give you as real an
impression of what you might have to do in the real world of accounting, I
deliberately use the second person "you" where others would use the first person
"I".
With only two accountants (a CPA supervisor an
assistant), you had to manage a wide variety of responsibilities. They mostly
consisted of handling accounts receivable, accounts payable, payroll and bank
reconciliations. Also, you were expected to write up special management reports,
attend board of directors' meetings, and conduct a daily audit of the flea
market field office a block down the street. These functions provided valuable
experience in various aspects of accounting and gave the most practical
applications of what is learned in college.
The accounts receivable function consisted of
recording tenants' rents due and payments received. From leases, you recorded
the amounts due onto the computer (the general ledger) and then again onto a
20-year old tome (the subledger). Then you sent bills to each tenant. In most
cases, tenants paid their bills timely with no problems. However, there were
many occasions in which tenants did not pay regularly– some did not pay even
after months of warnings and late fees. I recall a case where a well-known
politician had to "assist" a tenant in paying his rent. And there was another
where the tenant, a foreigner, could not read or write English well enough to
even write a check – you had to assist him. In yet another case, one woman did
not believe in checks, so she paid us thousands of dollars every month in cash.
Unfortunately, I have also seen tenants get locked out of their stores and sued
for default.
The accounts payable function consisted of
entering the vendor billings onto the computer, acquiring proper approvals for
payment, then cutting the checks, getting them signed, and distributing them to
the vendors. Sounds easy enough, right? Well, complications can occur if a
vendor-invoice exceeds a certain level: in that case, you needed two signatures
on the check – one from the director who was on site, and another from a board
member offsite. Some well-connected vendors, such as lawyers and artists, would
want to be paid on the day they presented their bill so that they would not have
to wait until the normal billing cycle. In other cases, some bills would go
months without being paid, perhaps due to an ongoing dispute between our company
and the vendor.
Employee payroll was done every Monday and
employees were paid bi-weekly on Friday. On Mondays there was a rush to properly
code and complete the hours on 60 payroll cards, check them against a control
list, and send them to City Hall's payroll department for processing. Some of
our employees worked overtime and required overtime pay. Others worked the
"graveyard" shift and required shift pay. There was sick leave, vacation leave,
back pay, leave without pay, and severance pay. Many people in our company
worked minimum wage jobs and lived paycheck-to-paycheck, so you did not want to
make a mistake or deny anyone his or her check.
Bank reconciliations consisted of acquiring bank
statements, canceled checks, prior reconciliations and other documents and
reporting differences in the bank balances versus the "booked" balances (those
on the general ledger). This was a tedious job with no real frills or
personalities to deal with.
The flea market field audit consisted of
counting the cash and checks in the flea market office and comparing the balance
to the registered sales reports for the day. Afterward, the accountant would
have to observe the courier and security guard deposit the money in the bank,
and get the receipt. Again, this was a minor task with no major issues to deal
with.
This company was not a regular company. While it
operated for a profit, it was a municipal operation wholly owned by the city.
Inasmuch, you were bound by city civil service rules and paid a municipal
salary. You rarely received raises, and those were often less than the yearly
cost of living increases. Also, because the firm made a lot of money and was
located in a popular tourist destination, it was highly sought after by local
politicians and interest groups. A large number of our expenses were
contributions to various charities, community causes, and event sponsorships,
not to mention a generous quarterly contribution to the city's general fund.
Due to the structure of the company – only a
chief accountant CPA and an assistant –the opportunities for advancement were
limited. If you wanted to stay at the local office, you would have to wait for
the chief accountant to retire. Otherwise, you would have to transfer to City
Hall or some other remote city agency.
On the positive side, this office usually had an
easygoing, pleasant environment, not to mention being situated in a gloriously
beautiful and exciting tourist destination. The company employees and customers
were from all walks of life, some young and single, others married with
children. After several years there, I came to view many of my coworkers as
friends and even like family.
Case 2:
The Utility Company
After I passed the CPA exam, I was lured away
from the tourist mecca by the big money and glamour of a national public utility
company. This company boasted of $1.4 billion in annual sales, 36 operations in
several states including Hawaii, and thousands of employees.
Instead of handling several functions, you were
a reporting accountant, charged with compiling and analyzing financial and
statistical reports on the company's many gas, electric, water and wastewater
treatment utilities. This entailed running computerized reports, poring through
hundreds of documents and putting together detailed income statements (called
"results of operations"). You and the other reporting accountants had to
transfer the information from original documents to Excel spreadsheets,
reclassify data to their correct accounts, then print original 700-page reports.
You would then take your originals and send them to a professional copy service
to be duplicated into 30 books. Hopefully the copy service would deliver them to
you in time for you to meet your deadline – you had 3 days after the month-end
close to distribute the books to board members and division controllers across
the country.
After that fire drill came financial analysis of
the reports. For every utility, you compared the actual income statement line
items to budget and to prior year, for current month and year-to-date figures.
You had to explain every variance that was material or not normal. To do so, you
conducted research. This research included reviewing journal entries, subsystem
reports, and other source documents as well as interviewing people in the
building or in the field (i.e., at the various locations around the nation). The
most frustrating parts of this job would be occasions when there was a lack of
information on an entry or no one who knew why a large variance occurred.
Another problem was "tying" the analyzed reports to the books sent to company
officials. Sometimes it would take hours to "tie-in" to the dollar with no
fudging. If someone from a distant location in the company came up with a source
document or report that differed from yours, you were in trouble.
The money and opportunities for advancement were
ideal. If you had the ability and aggressiveness, you could advance from a staff
accountant to a supervisor or even a director, easily commanding a salary close
to six figures. On the other hand, the daily office life was extremely
stressful. A normal workday was 10 hours plus, and you were working feverishly
the entire time to meet tough deadlines. Often you worked all weekend to get
reports out by early the next week. Supervisors were micro-managers and
taskmasters, constantly looking over your shoulder and having no tolerance for
mistakes or deviance from procedures. On top of that, the controller ruled with
an iron hand: he could call you minutes before closing time for a meeting, then
"grill" you on your reports late into the night.
Whereas the company was hiring many people the
first year I got there, by the second year the board of directors decided to go
in a different direction. The company eventually sold all of its public
utilities operations and invested in telecommunications in another state. This
resulted in the closing down of its local accounting operations and hiring an
outside accounting firm from New York to perform accounting functions.
It would be impossible to tell this story
without also adding that the company controller was indicted for stealing
millions from the firm. Essentially, he colluded with a board member to set up a
false vendor and diverted company funds to his own bank account. Of course, he
was terminated and had to repay the money, not to mention he now has to worry
about probable prison time. It was a textbook case of the cocky, shrewd
executive who put himself before his company. Now that executive will lose his
CPA privileges and not be able to work in accounting anymore. In the real world,
there are real, unethical people out there. Don't get caught up with that
because it will really destroy your accounting career – and at a time that you
least expect.
Case 3:
The Funeral and Cemetery Provider
Today I work for a 95-year old company based in
Louisiana that provides funeral services and cemetery products to some 110,000
customers in 27 states and Puerto Rico. It offers the best of all worlds:
interesting work, good pay, ample opportunities for advancement, a normal work
schedule, decent people and a pleasant work environment.
As a Balance Sheet Accountant, you analyze and
research the activity and balances in general ledger accounts and prepare
reports for management. My work can be divided into three main parts: (1) trust
accounts reconciliation, (2) other balance sheet accounts reconciliation, and
(3) other projects.
In trust account reconciliation, you are
expected to compare special bank account statements called trusts with the
company's books, then research, analyze and resolve differences. These trust
accounts can range from a few thousand dollars to many millions of dollars.
Because of the sheer volume of work (over 370 locations and 200 bank accounts),
poring through every single bank statement is impractical — you have to download
the bank and general ledger information using the computer into sub-reports.
Then you can review those reports, research and resolve problem items, reconcile
the bank accounts, then finally complete and distribute your final reports.
Along with the normal trust accounts to
reconcile, there are many other accounts to handle, both on the asset side of
the balance sheet and on the liabilities and equity side. These can range from
accounts receivable, inventory, deferred charges, fixed assets, accounts payable
and others. Unlike the income statement, where you are comparing an account to a
budget or prior period, on the balance sheet your goal is to compare the account
to a subledger and determine the proper level of the account. In real life,
subledgers do not always exist or cannot be easily compared to the general
ledger. Also, some accounts have balances that go back for years and no one
knows about them, or those who know no longer work for the company. Getting
information is always half the battle in accounting.
Other projects may include year-end account
analysis for the auditors, acquisition of customer contracts for management
reports, research of difficult problem accounts, documentation of an accounting
procedure or an account's functions, or just answering a request for
information. These cases test your flexibility, ability to learn new things,
communication and writing skills, understanding of the company business and
personnel structure, and just plain willingness to think through and solve
problems sensibly.
Advantages of having a CPA
In the accounting world, there are real and
tangible advantages being a certified public accountant. The rewards for passing
the exam include: a substantial increase in employment marketability and thus
compensation, eligibility to join national and state CPA societies, the ability
to practice public accounting as an independent CPA practitioner, and generally
the prestige and satisfaction of becoming a full member of a well-respected
professional community. No matter how well or poorly you did in college, once
you pass the CPA exam you immediately bolster yourself into the top 20
percentile of all accountants. After I passed the exam in 1998, I was able to
increase immediately my earnings by almost 30%.
However, be mindful that becoming a CPA is not
easy: You need 150 credit hours, or the equivalent of a Master's degree, just to
sit for the exam. It costs money to apply for the exam and hundreds of dollars
to take a review course. The exam itself only has about a 20-30% first-time
passing rate. Even if you overcome all those obstacles, it costs over $100 plus
40 continuing professional education (CPE) credits per year to maintain.
Final Considerations
The most enduring philosophy that I've run
across is that most of the obstacles in the real world come not from the work,
but from people. It just makes sense to be on good terms with the
decision-makers and to always be professional, friendly, patient, and
well-informed. I have noticed that the degreed, salaried workers doing
high-level duties like financial analysis often get more money and respect than
non-degreed wage employees doing menial tasks like collecting receipts. I have
also noticed that companies are constantly changing and it pays to be flexible
and up-to-date in your skill sets and knowledge.
In summary, the road to accounting success is a
self-paved road, where you have done your homework, selected your career based
on your personal definition of success, and been patient and flexible enough to
move on if the current situation changes. Most of all, you should go into a
career where you're doing what you love to do. A successful day in the real
world of work is probably best measured by how you talk about your job when you
return home.

Addison Carey III is an MBA accountant with Stewart
Enterprises.